| Year |
Player |
Team |
| 1942 |
Schubert (D) * |
1st |
| 1943 |
Michael Farina * |
1st |
| |
Jack Lilley (D) * |
1st |
| |
Manuel Montero * |
1st |
| |
John 'Bud' Palmer (D) * |
1st |
| |
Manuel Teran * |
1st |
| |
Felix Teran (GK) * |
1sy |
| 1950 |
Gustavo Gomez (F) * |
1st |
| 1951 |
Jacques Auguster (D) * |
1st |
| |
Walter Mueller * |
1st |
| 2009 |
Lincoln Field (M) ^ |
3rd |
* - Indicates that honors were recognized as Division I First Team All-America selections
^ - Indicates that honors were recognized as Division III All-America